Baytown officer fatally shoots woman who used his Taser against him, police say
A Baytown police officer shot and killed a woman moments after she yelled she was pregnant, according to a video of the Monday night confrontation.
While police later said the woman was not actually with child, the cell phone footage gained traction and quickly sparked a national response over the nature and justification of her shooting.
“Our Police Department takes incidents like this very seriously, and are therefore investigating the events which occurred last night ,” Mayor Brandon Capetillo said in a written statement. “This investigation is being jointly conducted by Baytown Police Detectives in cooperation with Investigators from the Harris County District Attorney’s Office.”
Residents described the woman, 44-year-old Pamela Turner, as quirky but a harmless neighbor. Police said the 11-year veteran of the police department who fired the shots “had prior dealings” with Turner and was trying to arrest her on an active warrant.
“It’s a tragic event for everybody involved,” department spokesman Lt. Steve Dorris said. “Of course, our hearts go out to the families of the deceased, as well as our officer.”
Authorities said Turner struck the unnamed officer with his own Taser at The Brixton Apartments at 1601 Garth Road. The events shown in the video unfold quickly and are difficult to interpret.
“You can’t tell from the video enough detail at this time to tell what’s happening,” said Larry Karson, an associate professor of criminal justice at UH-Downtown. “That’s the problem with these videos. Many people thought they’d be the silver bullet to solve what’s going on with police shootings.”
The encounter began around 10:30 p.m. Monday, after the officer spotted the woman while on patrol behind the complex, Dorris said. The officer approached the woman and tried to arrest her but she started struggling with him.
The officer deployed his Taser, but Turner was able to get the weapon away from him, Dorris said. She struck the officer with the Taser, at which point the officer pulled his firearm and fired five rounds, Dorris said.
The woman was struck at least once and died at the scene.
Dorris said the investigation was still in its early stages. Investigators didn’t know where the officer first approached the woman, he said.
The officer did not have to be taken to a hospital, he said.
One of the warrants for Turner’s arrest stemmed from an incident in which she allegedly assaulted the apartment manager after she had posted an eviction notice on Turner’s door April 24, court records show. That same day, the manager tried to get her to leave the apartment when Turner allegedly grabbed the manager’s face, scratching her nose and throwing her eyeglasses to the ground, court documents detail.
Turner also allegedly slammed a log through the windshield of someone else’s car days later, according to court records .
Turner was charged with two misdemeanor counts of criminal mischief for allegedly breaking the manager’s glasses and breaking the windshield, and one misdemeanor assault charge for allegedly scratching the manager, court documents show. She was not immediately arrested and was wanted on those charges at the time of Monday night’s shooting.
John Fullinwider, co-founder of the national advocacy group Mothers Against Police Brutality, said the video is clear: The officer appeared to create an unnecessary confrontation and further escalate the situation.
“What emergency existed, except the one he created?” he said. “If this officer had stepped back, it’s likely Ms. Turner would be alive today.”
The officer could have reasonably felt fear for his life, however, if the story he’s telling is what actually occurred, Karson said. That will make possible body camera footage critical in deciphering the shooting, he said.
“You have the officer stating that he was being attacked with the Taser, and from his position that could be life-threatening if successful, because he could easily be repeatedly tased, possibly disarmed,” Karson said. “In that venue, you can understand where an officer would have fear for their life.”
By Tuesday morning, only orange paint on the grass, left by investigators to mark the scene, indicated what happened the night before.
Neighbor Teryn Burns stood on her porch, recalling the last conversation she had with Turner. The woman said she’d found a pair of children’s shoes and was hoping to return them to their rightful owner.
“We talk to her every day,” Burns said. “She’s always out walking her dog. She brings little gifts here and there to the kiddos.”
Other residents in the complex said they were familiar with the woman, and that she frequently walked her dog and picked up trash in the area.
After watching the video, resident Johnathan Little said he felt the officer was in a position where force wasn’t necessary.
“That could have been one of our grandmas,” Little said. “I feel like everything went wrong.”