HOF or FOH: Michael Vick

[5th Letter]

I don't want to derail this too much. But I don't see how he has much of a case. Do we already have a HOF or FOH for him?

HOF or FOH: Donovan McNabb

37276 yards 59% completion 237 TD’s 6x pro bowl

ablackweb.com

 

[Bow to Royalty]

HOF or FOH: Donovan McNabb

37276 yards 59% completion 237 TD’s 6x pro bowl

ablackweb.com

Thanks. I remember that thread now. Lemme bring that back.

 

[Bow to Royalty]

I just posted in the McNabb HOF/FOH thread. I say definitely FOH. We can chop it up in there.

 

[Ibex]

Jackie Robinson is in the baseball HOF and his numbers are shit. He’s in off of impact and how he changed the game. Vick should get in for the same reasons.

 

[Hater Hearst Helmsley]

Jackie Robinson is in the baseball HOF and his numbers are shit. He’s in off of impact and how he changed the game. Vick should get in for the same reasons.

Did Vick break the color lines? There’s a major difference here.

 

[Dwayne]

Jackie Robinson is in the baseball HOF and his numbers are shit. He’s in off of impact and how he changed the game. Vick should get in for the same reasons.

He did not change the game. Not one bit.




Its only 1 Running QB in the league right now. So how he changed the game?

 

[5th Letter]

Vick was the NFL’s Iverson.

 

[Playmaker88]

He did not change the game. Not one bit.




Its only 1 Running QB in the league right now. So how he changed the game?

Bruh...he helped make the x factor aspect of black Qb's an appreciated thing

Russell Wilson
Mahomes
DeShaun
Jackson
Rg3

instead of jamming Qbs into a rigid system these guys are being alowed to use their attributes

the close mindedness of the prior eras is thawing thats a very big thing.

 

[Dwayne]

Bruh...he helped make the x factor aspect of black Qb's an appreciated thing

Russell Wilson
Mahomes
DeShaun
Jackson
Rg3

instead of jamming Qbs into a rigid system these guys are being alowed to use their attributes

the close mindedness of the prior eras is thawing thats a very big thing.

Naw.

Besides Jackson and RG3 them dudes are passers that can read and run ANY OFFENSE. Vick didnt do anything.



Mahomes had 218 yards
Watson had 413 yards and half of that is not design runs
Wilson had 342 yards and half of that is not design runs

 

[Playmaker88]

Naw.

Besides Jackson and RG3 them dudes are passers that can read and run ANY OFFENSE. Vick didnt do anything.



Mahomes had 218 yards
Watson had 413 yards and half of that is not design runs
Wilson had 342 yards and half of that is not design runs

the point eludes you all of these qbs have the ability to go off script and arent discouraged

 

[Dwayne]

the point eludes you all of these qbs have the ability to go off script and arent discouraged

That wasnt new with Vick. Not even close

Them dudes work the pocket and might try to get a few yards here and there. That was not new with Vick. Not at all


The AFC and NFC title game feature QBs with a less than 500 yards rushing combined.

If you say Lamar Jackson then yeah but no other QBs remotely plays even close to the way Vick did.

 

[5th Letter]

That wasnt new with Vick. Not even close

Them dudes work the pocket and might try to get a few yards here and there. That was not new with Vick. Not at all


The AFC and NFC title game feature QBs with a less than 500 yards rushing combined.

If you say Lamar Jackson then yeah but no other QBs remotely plays even close to the way Vick did.

Stop pretending to miss the point just to argue.

 

[Dwayne]

Stop pretending to miss the point just to argue.

Vick aint change the game because it hasnt worked year to year yet and proven to win. I stand by that.

Lamar Jackson has the chance prove it.

But until then

 

[5th Letter]

Vick aint change the game because it hasnt worked year to year yet and proven to win. I stand by that.

Lamar Jackson has the chance prove it.

But until then

You just want to argue. It’s cool though.

 

[Dwayne]

You just want to argue. It’s cool though.

So Vick is HOFer to you?

 

[5th Letter]

So Vick is HOFer to you?

Yes

 

[Bow to Royalty]

Yes

Im starting to think we disagree because you just have a lower bar for HOF. Quick check which of these guys do you have as HOF?

Eli
Rivers
Romo
Big Ben
Matt Ryan
Cam Newton
Flacco
Stafford

 

[Dwayne]

Im starting to think we disagree because you just have a lower bar for HOF. Quick check which of these guys do you have as HOF?

Eli
Rivers
Romo
Big Ben
Matt Ryan
Cam Newton
Flacco
Stafford

Eli
Rivers
Ben

 

[Bow to Royalty]

Eli
Rivers
Ben

I use to say Rivers, but I'm on the fence now. But if he gets in it'd be hard to make the argument to keep Ryan out.

 

[Dwayne]

I use to say Rivers, but I'm on the fence now. But if he gets in it'd be hard to make the argument to keep Ryan out.

Ryan gon end up top 10 in every category with MVP and Superbowl appearance