HOF or FOH: Donovan McNabb

[5th Letter]

37276 yards
59% completion
237 TD’s
6x pro bowl

 

[Chi-Town B]

He's a HOF'er without question

 

[Playmaker88]

HOF he was 1a with Manning for some years

damn shame he bitched up toward the end of his career

 

[Achewon87]

I think he should but probably won't make it...

 

[Mister B.]

McNabb is a HoF, just not first ballad. It’s gonna take 5-6 years, but he should be there. If Moon can make it, so can Donovan.

 

[wadupdoe!313]

mcnabb won't get in. he was borderline but his career ended with him out of shape and with a dud

 

[grYmes]

Had he won at least one Super Bowl there would be a strong case for him to be in sooner rather than later. Dude gonna be well into his 50s at least by the time it happens.

 

[Dwayne]

Yes

 

[BDBIID]

 

[Bow to Royalty]

FOH. He's gonna hit a log jam at QB because there's so much talent coming through. Peyton is almost eligible. Big Ben, Eli, Rivers, Brady, and Brees may all be retired in the next 2 years or so. Rodgers isn't far behind them.

Also he just doesn't deserve to get in. I had this debate before if the McNabb/Aikman thread. I think QB's can get in 2 ways; team accomplishments (Eli) or individual stats (Ryan and Rivers). McNabb doesn't have either on a HOF level.

 

[5th Letter]

Cmp%
60.1
Yds
35467
TD
237

Without looking it up. Guess who this is. This person has no rings and he’s in the hall.

 

[Hater Hearst Helmsley]

Cmp%
60.1
Yds
35467
TD
237

Without looking it up. Guess who this is. This person has no rings and he’s in the hall.

Same era as McNabb?

 

[Bow to Royalty]

Same era as McNabb?

Doubt it.

Spoiler: I looked it up

it's Jim Kelly. He came into the league 14-15 years before McNabb. It's true he has no rings, but he was a conference champ (a team accomplishment) 4 straight times.

 

[wadupdoe!313]

If a kicker makes a fg the bills win a superbowl.

McNabb not getting in

 

[Bow to Royalty]

HOF he was 1a with Manning for some years

damn shame he bitched up toward the end of his career

Naaah at the bolded.

 

[Achewon87]

Cmp%
60.1
Yds
35467
TD
237

Without looking it up. Guess who this is. This person has no rings and he’s in the hall.

Jim Kelly...

 

[5th Letter]

Same era as McNabb?

Nah

 

[5th Letter]

@Bow to Royalty did McNabb snub you on a autograph lol?

 

[Bow to Royalty]

@Bow to Royalty did McNabb snub you on a autograph lol?

Nah. Something inside me turns me into a hater when I think someone's over-hyped though, Haha. So I counter it until they're where they should be.

 

[Bow to Royalty]

Back to this!

McNabb deserves just about no HOF consideration. People are saying yes out of some emotional attachment.