Kanye - 5. Jay-Z - 3

[Revolver Ocelot]

Classics

RD
Volume 2
Blueprint
4:44
AG
Black Album

Nah 4:44 is just a great album after damn near a decade of trash.

It ain't no classic

 

[Loch121]

yall already listed what makes this false

Bout every other Jay album is a banger

His first 2 classic some will argue the 3rd album

Then Dynasty, Blueprint,Black album AG,BP 3,and 444

I would say 8=13 are classics

 

[HarryHippie]

Lmaooo dawg 444 is fuck no not a classic

The same niggas who don’t like To Pimp a Butterfly would call 444 a classic, the fuck times are we in

444 is a decent album, AG is my 3rd favorite Jay album, not classic. Neither of those albums are better than Life of Pablo so if we calling those classics, going have to add to Ye numbers

 

[Revolver Ocelot]

yall already listed what makes this false

Bout every other Jay album is a banger

His first 2 classic some will argue the 3rd album

Then Dynasty, Blueprint,Black album AG,BP 3,and 444

I would say 8=13 are classics

:sayword:

 

[Ibex]

I would give Jay 7 classics and Kanye 4

Reasonable Doubt
Vol. 1
Vol. 2
Blueprint
Black Album
American Gangster
4:44

College Dropout
Late Registration
Graduation
MBDTF

 

[Dwayne]

BP3 is a great album

 

[Revolver Ocelot]

BP3 is a great album

:sayword:

 

[grYmes]

444 is a decent album, AG is my 3rd favorite Jay album, not classic. Neither of those albums are better than Life of Pablo so if we calling those classics, going have to add to Ye numbers

Life of Pablo a trash ass album. I was with you on 4:44 but come on bruh.

 

[Loch121]

:sayword:

The Dynasty album is fire as fuck.I'll rock that shit rt now,today

BP 3 has NY on it and that was a moment,plus J Cole had his first major feature on that album on Star.

 

[God_Body]

Niggas on dust once again. Smh. Jay has 7 classic albums now? @Goldie add me to the podcast, somebody has to balance out the fuckery.

 

[Revolver Ocelot]

The Dynasty album is fire as fuck.I'll rock that shit rt now,today

BP 3 has NY on it and that was a moment,plus J Cole had his first major feature on that album on Star.

The bold I agree w/. But being a good/great album ain't the same as being a classic.

Even the worst of the worst albums got a song or 2 that's dope, and BP 3 falls into that category. Some nice tracks (Run This Town, DOA, ESOM, What we talkin' About, Already Home), but overall weak album.

 

[CeLLar-DooR]

Lmaooo dawg 444 is fuck no not a classic

The same niggas who don’t like To Pimp a Butterfly would call 444 a classic, the fuck times are we in

444 is a decent album, AG is my 3rd favorite Jay album, not classic. Neither of those albums are better than Life of Pablo so if we calling those classics, going have to add to Ye numbers

I don't think 4:44 a classic but its begge produced and way better lyrically than TPAB.

Both are much than the Life of Pablo

 

[Revolver Ocelot]

BP3 is a great album

BP 2 is considered a bad album but it has better songs on it than BP 3.

Meet the Parents
Some How Some Way
U Don't Know (Remix)
The Watcher 2
03 Bonnie & Clyde
Poppin' Tags
Blueprint 2
Guns & Roses
Excuse Me Miss

 

[BDBIID]

Depends on the generation

Ye prob does have 5 to younger gens

 

[Duwop]

Reasonable doubt- classic #1
Volume 2- classic #2
Blue print 1- classic #3
Black album- classic #4
American gangster-classic #5

I ain't gonna give much of an argument for 4:44....... It's right on the edge

 

[HarryHippie]

I don't think 4:44 a classic but its begge produced and way better lyrically than TPAB.

Both are much than the Life of Pablo

It’s Not and it’s not even close. So much so, I’m not willing to disrespect TPAB by having the discussion

 

[BDBIID]

BP3 is a great album

Hell no shit ass

& that’s coming from a Hovenger

 

[King Freeman]

 

[Sony Montana]

BP3 is a great album

 

[Hater Hearst Helmsley]

BP3 is a great album

nah but real as it gets still bangs in the whip