OPINION What's The Most Overrated HipHop "Classic" Album of Alltime?

[Goldie]

"My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy" is the most overrated album in the history of Rap

And there ain't a close 2nd

 

[Goldie]

Might need to update the "Classic or Nah" series.

Ill update the vault thread in a min.


Albums ABW voted on so far:


Classic:

The Black Album
HNIC
2001
Word of Mouf
Hell Hath No Fury
Urban Legend
God's Son (lol)
The Cool (lol)
And Then There Was X
Graduation
400 Degreez
Death Certificate
Ghetto D
E 1999
Carter 1
Documentary
TM101
Food & Liquor
Black On Both Sides
Ridin Dirty
Doe or Die
Regulate
Mista Dont Play
American Gangster
3 Feet and Rising
What Thee Album
Guerilla Warfare
MBDTF
GKMC
Dogg Food
Mr Smith
Minstrel Show
Da Dude (lol)
Kings of Crunk
Capital Pun
Vol2
Supreme Clientele
Forest Hill Drive
Creepin On Ah Come Up
Life After Death
Marshall Mathers LP





Not Classic:

Tical
Take Care
Genesis
The Inspiration
HipHop Is Dead
Juve The Great
Back For The First Time
Kiss The Game Goodbye
Warriors
King
Beg For Mercy
The World Is Yours
Big Bang
We Are The Streets
Guess Who's Back
VVV
Eminem Show
The Truth
Come Home With Me
I Am
R&G
Yeeeah Baby
808s & Heartbreak
Man on the Moon
Gangster and a Gentleman
Dreams & Nightmares
The Massacre
Doctor's Advocate

 

[AP2.5]

2001

 

[Sony Montana]

Forest hills drive

 

[Infamous114]

Might need to update the "Classic or Nah" series.

Ill update the vault thread in a min.


Albums ABW voted on so far:


Classic:

The Black Album
HNIC
2001
Word of Mouf
Hell Hath No Fury
Urban Legend
God's Son (lol)
The Cool (lol)
And Then There Was X
Graduation
400 Degreez
Death Certificate
Ghetto D
E 1999
Carter 1
Documentary
TM101
Food & Liquor
Black On Both Sides
Ridin Dirty
Doe or Die
Regulate
Mista Dont Play
American Gangster
3 Feet and Rising
What Thee Album
Guerilla Warfare
MBDTF
GKMC
Dogg Food
Mr Smith
Minstrel Show
Da Dude (lol)
Kings of Crunk
Capital Pun
Vol2
Supreme Clientele
Forest Hill Drive
Creepin On Ah Come Up
Life After Death
Marshall Mathers LP





Not Classic:

Tical
Take Care
Genesis
The Inspiration
HipHop Is Dead
Juve The Great
Back For The First Time
Kiss The Game Goodbye
Warriors
King
Beg For Mercy
The World Is Yours
Big Bang
We Are The Streets
Guess Who's Back
VVV
Eminem Show
The Truth
Come Home With Me
I Am
R&G
Yeeeah Baby
808s & Heartbreak
Man on the Moon
Gangster and a Gentleman
Dreams & Nightmares
The Massacre
Doctor's Advocate

Lol @ the lol's on the list

 

[Revolver Ocelot]

HNIC
Mista Dont Play
MBDTF
Da Dude (lol)
Kings of Crunk

bcuz none of these are classics

 

[Iceberg_Taylor]

All the Wayne albums I was told were classic

 

[Sony Montana]

I’m with the Goldster though

The cool isn’t a classic


Internet said it once and everybody ran with it

Kinda like Scarface/ghostface being in people’s top 5

 

[genocide_cutter]

None of my recommendations got voted to be classics.

 

[Goldie]

I’m with the Goldster though

The cool isn’t a classic


Internet said it once and everybody ran with it

Kinda like Scarface/ghostface being in people’s top 5

 

[AP2.5]

All the Wayne albums I was told were classic

By who?

 

[Iceberg_Taylor]

By who?

By society
What kinda question is this

 

[AP2.5]

By society
What kinda question is this

You better than this berg

 

[757'sFinest]

I ain't gonna say which one but I'm glad a certain album made the classic list

 

[Iceberg_Taylor]

You better than this berg

In this same thread The Carter 1 (lol) is listed as a classic. And don’t act like you haven’t heard ppl throw Classic around The Carter 3

I don’t write the lists don’t be mad at me

 

[5th Letter]

The Cool is not a classic.

 

[konceptjones]

All Eyes On Me.

 

[God_Body]

All the OutKast, Ice Cube, and Eminem albums I was told were classic.

 

[God_Body]

Nah, fuck that. To Pimp A Butterfly is the most overrated “classic” ever.

 

[Elzo69Renaissance]

99% of the “ classics” on that list are not classics