Montana vs Brady. Who's better?

Montana vs Brady. Who's better?

  • Montana

    Votes: 6 25.0%
  • Brady

    Votes: 18 75.0%

  • Total voters
    24
Brady.

Longer, less injury prone career.

If yall gonna claim Brady plays in a system then yall have to call out Montana for doing the same thing. Steve Young and Jeff Garcia were very successful running that offense.
 
Brady.

Longer, less injury prone career.

If yall gonna claim Brady plays in a system then yall have to call out Montana for doing the same thing. Steve Young and Jeff Garcia were very successful running that offense.

Well to be fair...they played in different eras, with different rules that didnt slant towards the Offensive side of the ball as well as the rules that have been created to protect the QB....which is a LARGE contributor to Brady's longevity...
 
Well to be fair...they played in different eras, with different rules that didnt slant towards the Offensive side of the ball as well as the rules that have been created to protect the QB....which is a LARGE contributor to Brady's longevity...
Imo both benefited from the era they played in.
Montana benefited from the lack of free agency. Getting to play with the same core of players year after year can only help a qb.

Brady benefits from the fact that if you touch him it is a felony.
 
just off of raw talent as a QB Brady not even top ten to keep it a buck
They both lack from the talent pool. Just curious tho.. What can Montana do that Brady can't?
From someone who doesn't follow this sport
What qb's would y'all suggest are massively talented then?
 
They both lack from the talent pool. Just curious tho.. What can Montana do that Brady can't?

That was my thought too, but I didn't want it to seem like I am being bias toward brady. So i wanted to stay out of it.
 
From someone who doesn't follow this sport
What qb's would y'all suggest are massively talented then?

I assume some would go with the Vick, Rodgers Mahomes...one who can run and throw bombs..

Marino arm along...and I probably wouldnt argue that

But the QB position is more about your mind than your physical gifts.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Revolver Ocelot
From someone who doesn't follow this sport
What qb's would y'all suggest are massively talented then?
John Elway was the epitome of talent. Can beat you with his gifted arm or beat you with his running ability. Elway was special. He is probably one of the highest rated prospects at qb ever.

Aaron Rodgers is special also. Golden arm that will make plays with his running ability.
 
I assume some would go with the Vick, Rodgers Mahomes...one who can run and throw bombs..

Marino arm along...and I probably wouldnt argue that

But the QB position is more about your mind than your physical gifts.
John Elway was the epitome of talent. Can beat you with his gifted arm or beat you with his running ability. Elway was special. He is probably one of the highest rated prospects at qb ever.

Aaron Rodgers is special also. Golden arm that will make plays with his running ability.
Ok i got it
 
You asked "What can Montana do that Brady can't?" and I answered what Montana DID do that Brady couldn't. I didn't say who was or who wasn't better.

To answer the question you just asked, Brady. Any other questions?

Well Montana can’t win 6