Is Tha Carter III a classic?

[Elzo69Renaissance]

Cruising while bumping that shit

That is a strong ass project

Culturally relevant, dope singles , dope album cuts

Moved major units

 

[TonyDubbz]

Yes

 

[AP2.5]

No

Glorified mixtape

Some solid tracks for sure, but it's the weakest of the first 3 as it's a total 180 from the previous 2 in terms of direction.

 

[Hater Hearst Helmsley]

No it is not

The original Carter 3>>>>The actual Carter 3

 

[illestni99ainne]

No. Carter 2>>>>>>>>>>>>

 

[Dwayne]

Yes.

 

[Hater Hearst Helmsley]

Yes.

Nah can’t have classics with phone home and mrs officer on the album

Handful of other tracks are cheeks too

 

[KINGEC]

No.

But this was my shit

 

[Based Dave 96]

NO.

 

[Sony Montana]

No

 

[Dwayne]

Nah can’t have classics with phone home and mrs officer on the album

Handful of other tracks are cheeks too

But Get Rich or Die trying a classic with PIMP 21 questions and In Da Club and a few other tracks that cheeks

 

[Hater Hearst Helmsley]

But Get Rich or Die trying a classic with PIMP 21 questions and In Da Club and a few other tracks that cheeks

All bangers

Many men
Backdown
Patiently waiting
What up gangsta
If I cant

All bangers

What are we doing here my brother

 

[Dwayne]

All bangers

Many men
Backdown
Patiently waiting
What up gangsta
If I cant

All bangers

What are we doing here my brother

Most overrated album of all time

 

[5th Letter]

Nope. It was a solid album though.

 

[AllElite617]

No.

 

[RozayTabernacle]

Songs like Comfortable, Tie My Hands, Shoot Me Down, Playing with Fire and Dontgetit aren't bad songs, but they are kinda forgettable.

La La and Piussy Monster are just wack.

Too many flaws to be a classic.

 

[Sony Montana]

Poll added

 

[LexDiamond1995]

Borderline

 

[Nope]

No

Glorified mixtape

Some solid tracks for sure, but it's the weakest of the first 3 as it's a total 180 from the previous 2 in terms of direction.

This is the reason I was put off by it.
I was expecting the Intro -Interlude and Outro like Carter 1 and 2 with Walk/Fly In and the rest.

The leaks didn’t help it either

 

[genocide_cutter]

No it is not

The original Carter 3>>>>The actual Carter 3