Melo vs Giannis

[Disanthrope]

That's fucking impressive. Only 9 people in the history of this league scored more than Melo. He may not get a ring and he made very poor career decisions just for money but this is something nobody can take from him

 

[King Freeman]

That's fucking impressive. Only 9 people in the history of this league scored more than Melo. He may not get a ring and he made very poor career decisions just for money but this is something nobody can take from him

But Giannis has a better career already.

 

[Dwayne]

But Giannis has a better career already.

He does.

 

[King Freeman]

He does not.

 

[Disanthrope]

He does.

How so?

 

[AP4.0]

Man make a thread... shit

 

[Dwayne]

How so?

2MVPs
1 DMVP

Melo don’t have 1 accomplishment on that level

 

[Disanthrope]

That 03 draft class was legendary

I think this 2020 class could be too

 

[King Freeman]

2MVPs
1 DMVP

Melo don’t have 1 accomplishment on that level

Giannis hasn't taken his team further than melo. That shit is hollow.

Guess steve nash better than melo too.

 

[Sky Davis]

wow carmelo has no all nba first team selections

shocking

 

[AZTG]

2MVPs
1 DMVP

Melo don’t have 1 accomplishment on that level

Im not disagreeing, but where do you factor longevitiy?

If Giannis has a career injury today, will you say his 4 year run of super elite play is greater than Melos 12 elite years, and 3 above average years?

And Melo might not have won mvp, but he was in the discussion a bunch of years.

So the question is, if Giannis' career ended today, does Giannis being a top 3 player for 4 years trump Melo being a top 10 player for almost 10 years?

 

[Disanthrope]

Man make a thread... shit

A good thread would be: would Miami have won rings with Melo instead of Bosh?

 

[Sky Davis]

Giannis hasn't taken his team further than melo. That shit is hollow.

Guess steve nash better than melo too.

by your logic,

Jimmy butler has taken his team further than AI

is he better all time then?

I don’t have the energy for a reply I’m dealing with Pimp C

 

[AZTG]

wow carmelo has no all nba first team selections

shocking

Lets keep it real, alot of that had to do with playing for the nuggets.

Melos best years was with the nuggets, if he had those years on a big market team, he would have had a few all nba selections.

 

[King Freeman]

Im not disagreeing, but where do you factor longevitiy?

If Giannis has a career injury today, will you say his 4 year run of super elite play is greater than Melos 12 elite years, and 3 above average years?

And Melo might not have won mvp, but he was in the discussion a bunch of years.

So the question is, if Giannis' career ended today, does Giannis being a top 3 player for 4 years trump Melo being a top 10 player for almost 10 years?

Common sense ain't that common.

 

[King Freeman]

by your logic,

Jimmy butler has taken his team further than AI

is he better all time then?

I don’t have the energy for a reply I’m dealing with Pimp C

That's not my logic. Don't twist what I'm saying to get your dumbass shit off.

 

[Iceberg_Taylor]

by your logic,

Jimmy butler has taken his team further than AI

is he better all time then?

I don’t have the energy for a reply I’m dealing with Pimp C

how has Jimmy gone further than AI?

 

[Infamous114]

how has Jimmy gone further than AI?

Jimmy won 2 games in the Finals. AI won 1 (I'm aware it was the same result for both)

 

[Sky Davis]

That's not my logic. Don't twist what I'm saying to get your dumbass shit off.

If you say so

 

[Disanthrope]

how has Jimmy gone further than AI?

Jimmy won 2 games in the finals. AI won 1

Petty af lol