Melo vs Giannis

[Dwayne]

Im not disagreeing, but where do you factor longevitiy?

If Giannis has a career injury today, will you say his 4 year run of super elite play is greater than Melos 12 elite years, and 3 above average years?

And Melo might not have won mvp, but he was in the discussion a bunch of years.

So the question is, if Giannis' career ended today, does Giannis being a top 3 player for 4 years trump Melo being a top 10 player for almost 10 years?

Yes. Giannis run is more impressive

10x All Star
6x All-NBA (no first team. 2nd and
2012-2013 scoring champ

Vs

5x All Star
4x All NBA (2x first team)
3x All Defensive (2x first team)
2x MVP
1x DMVP

I feel GA has done more with less time

 

[Iceberg_Taylor]

I know we not doing that here right now.

 

[Suckio Andretti]

Lets keep it real, alot of that had to do with playing for the nuggets.

Melos best years was with the nuggets, if he had those years on a big market team, he would have had a few all nba selections.

But...Giannis isn’t on a big market team and has 2

 

[Dwayne]

You can add another all defensive and all nba to GA accomplishments for this year too.

 

[Dwayne]

But...Giannis isn’t on a big market team and has 2

 

[Disanthrope]

Yes. Giannis run is more impressive

10x All Star
6x All-NBA (no first team. 2nd and
2012-2013 scoring champ

Vs

5x All Star
4x All NBA (2x first team)
3x All Defensive (2x first team)
2x MVP
1x DMVP

I feel GA has done more with less time

Damn..uh... You forgot Melos gold medals tho

 

[Chi-Town B]

These would be great threads, why don't y'all ever make them

 

[Suckio Andretti]

Dwight Howard has taken his team as far as AI has and further than carmelo

so how much stock are we gonna put in that?

 

[Dwayne]

Who you think has the more impressive career.
As of today the accomplishments is listed below

Melo 2003-2021
10x All Star
6x All-NBA (no first team. 2nd and
2012-2013 scoring champ

Vs

Giannis 2013-2021
5x All Star
4x All NBA (2x first team)
3x All Defensive (2x first team)
2x MVP
1x DMVP

I’m pretty sure you can add another All NBA and All Defensive team selection to GA list

 

[Shaquille Sunflower]

Dwight Howard has taken his team as far as AI has and further than carmelo

so how much stock are we gonna put in that?

2 different positions

 

[Suckio Andretti]

2 different positions

won’t matter when you look back on selections

look at Kobe defensive team awards lol

 

[Dwayne]

Who you think has the more impressive career.
As of today the accomplishments is listed below

Melo 2003-2021
10x All Star
6x All-NBA (no first team. 2nd and
2012-2013 scoring champ

Vs

Giannis 2013-2021
5x All Star
4x All NBA (2x first team)
3x All Defensive (2x first team)
2x MVP
1x DMVP

I’m pretty sure you can add another All NBA and All Defensive team selection to GA list

@AZTG
@King Freeman

y’all saying that’s not more impressive?

 

[Shaquille Sunflower]

When Giannis put up numbers for 20 years we can have this discussion

 

[Dwayne]

When Giannis put up numbers for 20 years we can have this discussion

Has Melo accomplished more that GA yes or no?

 

[AP3.0]

And let's be honest, melon knows exactly why he was out of a job for 2 years.

I wish he stop with this

He thought he was still the first option when that ship had long sailed.

 

[King Freeman]

@AZTG
@King Freeman

y’all saying that’s not more impressive?

I think melo being top 10 points all time is greater than a couple hollow MVP's.

The longevity, influence, and where you line up against the best of all time means something.

You can't just dismiss that.

 

[Dwayne]

I think melo being top 10 points all time is greater than a couple hollow MVP's.

The longevity, influence, and where you line up against the best of all time means something.

Really? MVPs ain’t a mark of greatness or are you saying HIS MVPs ain’t shit?

So you just gon skip over the defensive accomplishments too?

 

[Dwayne]

And what has Melo really influenced?

Let’s break it down.

 

[AP3.0]

And what has Melo really influenced?

Let’s break it down.

Iso play on the wing with no screen

 

[Dwayne]

Iso play on the wing with no screen

Can’t forget the hoodie