OUT NOW Jay Electronica "A Written Testimony" Album Thread

[Race Jones]

I didn't

Dada right back in here

But y'all making a bigger deal out of it than it needs to be

ok well nevermind

i apologize

 

[AP3.0]

was they banned or not ap!

Banned?

No

Put on timeout? Yes

They both back in here. Sooooo what's the issue queen

 

[Inori]

 

[Old Man Cain]

also @Goldie AP cant ban ppl for having an opinion

that needs to stop asap

Yep you never posted on the IC. Niggas got banned for typing in the wrong font color....
.yes I did that

MWOF&NEY(mod without feelings and never explain yourself)

 

[Race Jones]

Banned?

No

Put on timeout? Yes

They both back in here. Sooooo what's the issue queen

you cant put ppl on timeout for having an opinion

cut that stupid shit out

 

[Goldie]

Will you stop posting this geek

 

[Old Man Cain]

Looks like Cain was the first to catch the Roni

No sir. Wayne is ok rapper at best Jay E is better.

Jay E bars on Neverending Story >>>>>>>Jay's

 

[Race Jones]

Yep you never posted on the IC. Niggas got banned for typing in the wrong font color....
.yes I did that

MWOF&NEY(mod without feelings and never explain yourself)

BYE CAIN!

 

[Inori]

Will you stop posting this geek

It's an interesting conversation

:ualreadyknow:

 

[Goldie]

lol i'm just talkin shit. His list was trash tho.

 

[Duwop]

I don't know what's going on with y'all....

But you know an album is good when it starts breaking up friendships....

:ualreadyknow:

 

[Old Man Cain]

BYE CAIN!

Come here you!!!!

 

[Elzo69Renaissance]

We gonna need a 30 for 30 documentary on Jay Electronica

 

[CeLLar-DooR]

All what Lupe is saying is no different to asking the question, "who's the greatest rapper of all time?" etc

In order to quantify it, you need to set the parameters of how you want it to be judged. and then once you set the parameters, you still need to give weightings to each criteria, as some should hold more weight than others.

For classic example, the criteria of album sales/number #1s/gold, platinum plaques etc.

It we take discography and catalogue into the discussion, then do we look at it solely on albums (i.e. commercial released body of work) or overall quality of substance of songs released? If it's the former, then Joe's point is clearly a valid one but is it really right to look and critique Jay E off of this latest project? So we gonna dismiss all the songs prior which weren't commercial releases or in album format - let's be honest, if Jay E wasn't a mastery prior to Written Testimony then why was there so much anticipation for him to drop the album in the first place? There's truth on all sides, but for Joe to completely dismiss Jay E in any convos with the elite and top tier rappers is IMO naive and asinine

It's not so much that


would you tell a contractor how to build a house if you've never built one?


it's 1 thing to say if you like it or not, a whole nother to suggest how it should be done if you've never done it

My bruddas he quite clearly says only rap masters can validly judge other rap masters

 

[Old Man Cain]

Does Lupe still rap or is he a samauri mountain climber? Not even joking

 

[Mister]

Will you stop posting this geek

That's Grand Master Lupe to you, sir.

 

[Shaquille Sunflower]

We gonna need a 30 for 30 documentary on Jay Electronica

would be a waste of film

 

[Mister]

It's an interesting conversation

:ualreadyknow:

Could be an interesting thread/series on here as well...

 

[Elzo69Renaissance]

would be a waste of film

Nah a great story to be told

 

[TonyDubbz]

I wouldn't of made it through this shit without Hov on it honestly, I was surprised that I had even made it off the first track

Jesus fuckin christ

View attachment 247864