HOF or FOH: Amare Stoudemire

[AP4.0]

I'm going with nah

I wanna compare his career with and without Nash though

 

[John Shippuden]

Yo @5th Letter how can you be a superstar/HOFer when you was never the primary option on offense for a full season?

 

[AZTG]

Injuries robbed him of a potential HOF career imo.

Had he sustaines what he did his first half season in NY before Melo got there and he got injured for 4-5 years on top of his years with the Suns, he woulda been in imo

 

[John Shippuden]

Aldridge, Randolph, love, Griffin, Bosh, got a better chance at the hall than Amare


Eh never mind this is obvious

 

[wadupdoe!313]

may as well put amare in. Everybody makes the basketball HOF. Hell Kevin Johnson is in the HOF.

 

[John Shippuden]

Tim hardaway ain’t because he hates gay people

 

[5th Letter]

Yo @5th Letter how can you be a superstar/HOFer when you was never the primary option on offense for a full season?

So he gets penalized for playing with another superstar?

 

[John Shippuden]

So he gets penalized for playing with another superstar?

Lol @ another superstar

That implies that there were two

Well let me ask you...is Klay Thompson being penalized in circles for always having curry? Is he considered a superstar?

 

[5th Letter]

Lol @ another superstar

That implies that there were two

Well let me ask you...is Klay Thompson being penalized in circles for always having curry? Is he considered a superstar?

No because you’re comparing apples to oranges. People said Amare wasn’t shit without Nash yet he won rookie of the year without Nash, had another season the year before they got Nash. He went to NY and was an all star putting up superstar numbers.

 

[John Shippuden]

No because you’re comparing apples to oranges. People said Amare wasn’t shit without Nash yet he won rookie of the year without Nash, had another season the year before they got Nash. He went to NY and was an all star putting up superstar numbers.

Amare ain’t shit without Felton and Nash then

 

[5th Letter]

Amare ain’t shit without Felton and Nash then

Now you just hating

 

[John Shippuden]

Now you just hating

Lol I wasn’t serious

 

[VulcanRaven]

Nash made dude

Yeah without Nash he was trash.

 

[Mister Breeze]

 

[#1hiphopjunki3]

He was a good player in his prime but injuries cut his career short and he doesn’t have a good enough resume outside the NBA to get him in

 

[Revolver Ocelot]

Nope

But he might get in anyway.

 

[VulcanRaven]

He was a good player in his prime but injuries cut his career short and he doesn’t have a good enough resume outside the NBA to get him in

He didn't look good without Nash. Was not the same in NY. I seen that thumbs down. Nash made that guy a star in Phoenix.

 

[John Shippuden]

Where’s the next thread?

 

[#1hiphopjunki3]

He didn't look good without Nash. Was not the same in NY. I seen that thumbs down. Nash made that guy a star in Phoenix.

He played pretty good with the Knicks before his injuries. He averaged 25 and 8 on good shooting % and helped get them in the playoffs

 

[5th Letter]

Where’s the next thread?

Will be football related