Poll Best Movie Tournament (Rd1): Logan vs Iron Man

[Goldie]

vs

 

[mike030270]

IM1 was great but Logan was just different and on another level

 

[God_Body]

The fact that Iron Man made the best 2008 movie list is absurd.

 

[God_Body]

@illestni99ainne google it nigga. Like how?

 

[LexDiamond1995]

Iron Man changed the game.....like literally

If Iron Man flopped, there would be no MCU

 

[Norrin_Radd]

@illestni99ainne google it nigga. Like how?

One of the most popular and profitable movies absolutely deserves to be there

 

[God_Body]

One of the most popular and profitable movies absolutely deserves to be there

 

[Norrin_Radd]

Ok guy

 

[Inglewood_B]

This shouldn’t be close.

Love what RDJ and IronMan started… but get this the fuck outta here

 

[God_Body]

Iron Man changed the game.....like literally

If Iron Man flopped, there would be no MCU

That doesn’t mean it was the best cinema had to offer in 2008. Isn’t that the purpose of this tournament, is to the pick the best movies base off plot, actors, cinematography, and sound not fuckin profitable and popularity.

 

[LexDiamond1995]

That doesn’t mean it was the best cinema had to offer in 2008. Isn’t that the purpose of this tournament, is to the pick the best movies base off plot, actors, cinematography, and sound not fuckin profitable and popularity.

Iron Man had all that and was 1 of the best reviewed movies of 2008.

 

[Duwop]

Wasn't a big fan of Logan

 

[God_Body]

Iron Man had all that and was 1 of the best reviewed movies of 2008.

But it was other movies that did it better, that’s the point. Where is it critical acclaim movie nominations at. It’s not even the best comic book movie of 08.

 

[God_Body]

Also, Blade saved Marvel Studios. Not Iron Man.

 

[LexDiamond1995]

Also, Blade saved Marvel Studios. Not Iron Man.

Blade helped Marvel studios for sure in 98 but they still were on shaky ground in the early 2000s before Iron Man dropped

 

[Infamous114]

Iron Man got nominated for 2 Oscars lol. Logan got nominated for 1. Iron Man got nominated for 1 SAG award, Logan got nominated for 1 SAG award. There goes that stupid argument.

 

[God_Body]

We counting CGI noms. Gotcha. Automatic ABW best movie of the year nomination. And I’m comparing Ironman to the class of 08 movies not Logan, dipshit.

 

[Suckio Andretti]

We don’t have to do this every time man

 

[Suckio Andretti]

This is tough because I find parts of Logan boring and the locations/girl I largely didn’t care about

Villain whose name I forget was eh. Didn’t take him seriously

Hmm idk

 

[AP3.0]

This is tough because I find parts of Logan boring and the locations/girl I largely didn’t care about

Villain whose name I forget was eh. Didn’t take him seriously

Hmm idk

I went with Logan for the fact that it seemed like the stakes mattered in a meaningful way

It was about as "real" as you could get for the source material

In other words, if this was just a movie with no comic book elements, no mutant, no abilities, I would still think it was a solid choice of the two.