Rd1: Goat Female RnB 90s Song: Fantasy Rmx vs If Your Girl Only Knew

[Chi-Town B]

I refuse to believe yall niggas ridin around to "im in heavennn , with my boyfriend, my lovely boyfriend"

Yall just voting for the bigger song

We know damn well you ain't in the whip bumping Aaliyah. Anything Mariah shits on anything Aaliyah

 

[AP3.0]

Yeah, I'm about to institute a drug testing policy to post here

I'm sick of this shit

 

[Goldie]

We know damn well you ain't in the whip bumping Aaliyah. Anything Mariah shits on anything Aaliyah

I can blast "one in a million" in any hood and have the whole hood jamin.

Shit, i was just playin this joint the other day

 

[Chi-Town B]

Yeah, I'm about to institute a drug testing policy to post here

I'm sick of this shit

Aaliyah is overrated, I honestly don't know why y'all surprised the votes are like they are. I should be pissed that Whitney losing in the other thread.

 

[AP3.0]

Aaliyah is overrated, I honestly don't know why y'all surprised the votes are like they are. I should be pissed that Whitney losing in the other thread.

Is she the most talented vocalist?

No, but is the song that's matched up against her the better song? Hell no

I don't think y'all know what y'all supposed to be judging

 

[Dwayne]

Is she the most talented vocalist?

No, but is the song that's matched up against her the better song? Hell no

I don't think y'all know what y'all supposed to be judging

She dont have any talent when it comes to her vocals she is bottom tier

But hooks and beats is why she getting votes

Her songs are ok as far as content but its Hooks and Beats though

My Take

 

[5th Letter]

Is she the most talented vocalist?

No, but is the song that's matched up against her the better song? Hell no

I don't think y'all know what y'all supposed to be judging

What are we supposed to be judging?

 

[5th Letter]

But hooks and beats is why she getting votes

Her songs are ok as far as content but its Hooks and Beats though

Yup. And I fuxs with baby girl...

 

[Goldie]

Aaliyah is better than Mariah, period.

Give me an authentic rnb urban track over a pop song with a rapper thrown on it. Mariah ain't start making true rnb till she linked with Puff on honey. And even that shit aint fuckin with aaliyah's best shit.

 

[Goldie]

And yea ik puff produced "fantasy remix" but it still started as a pop song.

 

[AP3.0]

What are we supposed to be judging?

The better song

I'm with Goldie on the one. Niggas is not bumping fantasy with odb.

If your girl only knew is the better song

Better lyrics
Better production
More relatable

Yes Aaliyah, vocally couldn't touch practically anyone during her run, but she made some good ass songs

Hell, Bryson Tiller can't sing a lick but "sorry not sorry" will get more burn than a nigga song with a better voice if the lyrics trash

 

[5th Letter]

The better song

I'm with Goldie on the one. Niggas is not bumping fantasy with odb.

If your girl only knew is the better song

Better lyrics
Better production
More relatable

Yes Aaliyah, vocally couldn't touch practically anyone during her run, but she made some good ass songs

Hell, Bryson Tiller can't sing a lick but "sorry not sorry" will get more burn than a nigga song with a better voice if the lyrics trash

Bruh better song is subjective

 

[Dwayne]

The better song

I'm with Goldie on the one. Niggas is not bumping fantasy with odb.

If your girl only knew is the better song

Better lyrics
Better production
More relatable

Yes Aaliyah, vocally couldn't touch practically anyone during her run, but she made some good ass songs

Hell, Bryson Tiller can't sing a lick but "sorry not sorry" will get more burn than a nigga song with a better voice if the lyrics trash

Naw. Bryson has good songs

Baby Girl has good hooks and beats

 

[BDP™️]

Mariah got an all time great voice

But as a complete artist...

Im going with Aaliyah

 

[BDP™️]

Naw. Bryson has good songs

Baby Girl has good hooks and beats

Stop.

 

[AP3.0]

Bruh better song is subjective

What's better about fantasy in your opinion

 

[Black]

MC.

 

[BDP™️]

Back and Forth
At Your Best
One In A Million
4 Page Letter
Hot Like Fire
IYGOK
Are You That Somebody
More Than A Woman
Try Again
Rock The Boat
I Care 4 U

And im sure im missing some...

Baby Girl got SONGS for days

 

[Black]

Aaliyah is better than Mariah, period.

Give me an authentic rnb urban track over a pop song with a rapper thrown on it. Mariah ain't start making true rnb till she linked with Puff on honey. And even that shit aint fuckin with aaliyah's best shit.

No she aint better than Mariah lmao.

 

[Dwayne]

Yall telling me Aaliyah aint nothing but hooks and beats?








Yall tripping







Her songs are cool but nothing great. When it comes to R&B i like to here a unique or great voice along with great song