Rd1: Goat Female RnB 90s Song: Fantasy Rmx vs If Your Girl Only Knew

[Goldie]

vs






​

 

[Goldie]

The beat alone on "If Your Girl Only Knew" , once that mf drops :wdf2:

 

[Norrin_Radd]

This is a tough choice but slight edge to Fantasy just for ODB. Only reason I listen to that song. RIP

 

[AP3.0]

I prefer the darker theme over the pop song for this matchup

 

[Chi-Town B]

Why do y'all keep voting against legendary songs, Goldie got y'all brainwashed

 

[Goldie]

They're both legendary songs fam

 

[Chi-Town B]

They're both legendary songs fam

Aaliyah's songs isn't legendary

 

[Matike85]

Me & Mariah FTW

 

[Loquacious]

Aaliyah got this.

 

[5th Letter]

I like them both but i edge this one to Mariah.

 

[Chi-Town B]

Even the version without ODB would be a top contender to win the whole thing

 

[JJ Evans]

I was actually gonna give this one to Mariah, but I kinda remember a controversy surrounding this song. She and her record company purposely pushed the song, minus ODB, to white media outlets because they didn’t want to come off as too black. They pushed this ODB version to black media outlets.

For that reason, I give this round to Babygirl instead.

Someone correct me if I’m remembering this incorrectly.

 

[Chi-Town B]

I was actually gonna give this one to Mariah, but I kinda remember a controversy surrounding this song. She and her record company purposely pushed the song, minus ODB, to white media outlets because they didn’t want to come off as too black. They pushed this ODB version to black media outlets.

For that reason, I give this round to Babygirl instead.

Someone correct me if I’m remembering this incorrectly.

She wanted to reach more into the urban market and work with hip hop acts her label didn't. She won and that's why she started working with Puff, Bone Thugs and other hip hop related artists

 

[Playmaker88]

Tough match up odd comparison.. given a remix but

S00-yung!

 

[T. Sanford]

The beat alone on "If Your Girl Only Knew" , once that mf drops :wdf2:

Timbo was in his bag in 96'. This song should be winning the race

 

[5th Letter]

Fantasy is one of the definitive songs of the 90’s. It has to at least win a round not saying it should win the tournament though.

 

[Hater Hearst Helmsley]

Mariah easily.

 

[Dwayne]

Watch Aaliyah will the entire thing.










The woman with the weakest voice in the entire tournament






She got hits though. even though I feel her songs are more hip hop/pop

 

[5th Letter]

Watch Aaliyah will the entire thing.










The woman with the weakest voice in the entire tournament






She got hits though. even though I feel her songs are more hip hop/pop

It’s them Timbaland beats.

 

[Goldie]

I refuse to believe yall niggas ridin around to "im in heavennn , with my boyfriend, my lovely boyfriend"

Yall just voting for the bigger song