HOF or FOH: Cam Newton

[5th Letter]

2015 NFL MVP
1X All Pro
3X Pro Bowl
2011 Rookie of The Year
32382 Yards
194 TD’s
5628 Rush Yards
75 Rush TD’s

 

[O.G.]

Shoulda jumped on that fumble in the super bowl.

 

[Dwayne]

42. Passes Completed
44. Passing yards
55. Passing TDs
59. Completion %

It’s a easy FOH for me

 

[Revolver Ocelot]

 

[Ghostface]

HELL NO!!!!!!!!

 

[Marc123]

Should have dived for that fumble in the SB

 

[Revolver Ocelot]

Should have dived for that fumble in the SB

Even if he did and they won the game. If his career still played out the way it did. He still wouldn't be a HOFer.

 

[mike030270]

He fell off big time. Not sure if that was injuries or what but damn

 

[Dwayne]

He fell off big time. Not sure if that was injuries or what but damn

skills.

 

[mike030270]

skills.

I can't remember if it was 2020 or this past season but he couldn't throw worth a damn after his surgery

 

[VulcanRaven]

It's gone take a long time. Winning an MVP makes his case but way down the line

 

[grYmes]

It's gone take a long time. Winning an MVP makes his case but way down the line

 

[Dwayne]

I can't remember if it was 2020 or this past season but he couldn't throw worth a damn after his surgery

Even before that.

Bruh was was always below average throwing the ball. Lucky he can run and had an elite defense with him. But he’s not even close to being anything but a QB that has a lucky run but was not good for most of his career.

 

[Marc123]

Even if he did and they won the game. If his career still played out the way it did. He still wouldn't be a HOFer.

idk. I think if cam won a SB and SB MVP he would be a HOF

 

[Dwayne]

idk. I think if cam won a SB and SB MVP he would be a HOF

How Sway?

 

[Marc123]

How Sway?

idk tbh i jus feel that way.

Look at like this. If he won...

1 league MVP (which he did)
1 SB
1 SB MVP

Add in his decent to solid numbers over his career. That feels like HOF imo

 

[Dwayne]

idk tbh i jus feel that way.

Look at like this. If he won...

1 league MVP (which he did)
1 SB
1 SB MVP

Add in his decent to solid numbers over his career. That feels like HOF imo

Solid numbers in this passing era?

All his numbers was below average though. Literally all of them besides running TDs

 

[Marc123]

Solid numbers in this passing era?

All his numbers was below average though. Literally all of them besides running TDs

 

[Revolver Ocelot]

idk tbh i jus feel that way.

Look at like this. If he won...

1 league MVP (which he did)
1 SB
1 SB MVP

Add in his decent to solid numbers over his career. That feels like HOF imo

Yeah, he would have achieved a lot in his 1st 4 seasons, and the last 5-6 seasons would have folks like "what if"

Not an HOFer

 

[south4life]

Nigga is Hella arrogant!
He fucked himself up after he said "If you don't like me dancing, stop me".
They started bombing on him and he stayed hurt after.