I like Scarface, but he's ranked way too high. There's too many other MCs who are better than him in a handful of categories for him to be top 5.
Ice Cube was Kendrick before Kendrick was Kendrick. Ice Cube not only sonically elevated the game but visually as well. Even his character portrayals in movies are classic and brought significant social commentary to some of the ills facing black America in perhaps one of the most Afrocentric periods in history. Listen to his first 3 albums back to front. Even his contribution to NWA.
Same goes for Scarface he was instrumental to the expansion of Southern Hip Hop and could be hailed the King of the South.
And as for Black Thought. His choice for Tariq Trotter is just as valid as your choice for Andre 3000 being a GOAT contender. 3k doesn't have any real rap albums he has verses. Many of the songs he's featured on are curated and are the product of Big Boi's creativity. At least Black has actually spearheaded numerous albums as leader of The Roots some of which are deemed as classics to pop culture.
Yall niggas nosigning, but can't combat anything I said. When we're talking about God level MCs, those mfs don't deserve to even be in the conversation.
Pac wasn't a "God level MC" but he's in your top 5.
Say something that that doesn't have something to do with them niggas being old niggas in the game.
Dr J was Jordan before Jordan, Rakim was Nas before Nas, etc. That's a tired and lame excuse for why somebody's superior or even on the same level.
Everybody has predecessors. The iphone made the iphone x possible, is the iphone better than the iphone 10? Fuck no.
What else do you have other than "he paved the way"?
But he was, damn near every category covered at a high level
Nigga nobody refers to Pac as an God level MC, not even you.
That's why you used Jay as your example and not Pac.
I knew what you meant, you was referring to strictly lyrical ability