Nah bro, not all star level production. 24-30 players (depending on injury) make the All Star team. Just scroll through this page and look at all the players that had stronger seasons number wise that were not considered all star worthy.
ESPN is the place for NBA stats! Discover the All Positions stat leaders of the 2019-20 NBA Regular Season.
www.espn.com
For example, Ayton was 18 points, 11.5 rebs and 1.5 blocks with good efficiency.
As for Horford, that was more of a narrative selection bcos of how the Hawks were doing that season.