Poll Classic or Nah: Marshall Mathers LP

[5 Grand]

It's a 5-star classic. Back in the old IC that was common knowledge.

MMLP was never a 5 mic classic.

White people hyped it up when it was out but Black people never fucked with it like that.

 

[genocide_cutter]

Do my recommendation next

 

[OGDirtyD]

MMLP was never a 5 mic classic.

White people hyped it up when it was out but Black people never fucked with it like that.

Boy lying out his teeth or was too old to understand the pulse at the time.

 

[5 Grand]

Boy lying out his teeth or was too old to understand the pulse at the time.

Are you saying you knew Black people circa 2000 that thought MMLP was a 5 mic classic?

 

[OGDirtyD]

Are you saying you knew Black people circa 2000 that thought MMLP was a 5 mic classic?

10000%

 

[Lab Baby]

Are you saying you knew Black people circa 2000 that thought MMLP was a 5 mic classic?

I'm from Brownsville. Niggas was playing that joint everywhere. I damn near had to fight my cousin to borrow that album.

 

[Lab Baby]

Perfect album? Not by a long shot. Aged well? Not so much... niggas don't wanna hear psycho raps, fan stalking and juggalo fellatio in 2025. But MMLP was a moment in time those of us who were around will never forget. Love it or hate it, Em dropped a nuke on the world. Nigga outsold NSYNC, Backstreet Boys, Britney Spears and Christina Aguilera... in 2000. Ain't that many white ppl in the world that wanna hear a dude rap fast and loud about killing his mother. Em was just him.

 

[Loneshot]

I don't agree that it didn't age well, because I still listen to at least five of these songs regularly.

 

[Lab Baby]

I don't agree that it didn't age well, because I still listen to at least five of these songs regularly.

Which ones? I'm listening to it now. There's isn't really a bad song on there, but society has moved on from that subject matter. Kill You is considered a flight risk in 2025.

 

[Loneshot]

Which ones? I'm listening to it now. There's isn't really a bad song on there, but society has moved on from that subject matter. Kill You is considered a flight risk in 2025.

The Way I Am never left the rotation.
Bitch Please
Who Knew
Stan
The Real Slim Shady
Drug Ballad

 

[5th Letter]

B Please 2 is the best song on there.

 

[Lab Baby]

The Way I Am never left the rotation.
Bitch Please
Who Knew
Stan
The Real Slim Shady
Drug Ballad

These, Marshall Mathers, Amityville, Remember Me and Criminal are my shits. Em's last verse on Amityville... SHEESH.

 

[#1hiphopjunki3]

Nah

Yo!

this was actually a solid song. had me shaking my head. LOL

 

[CaptainJackson]

This album aged terribly.

How?

 

[400Degreez]

How?

You're not getting a titangraph from me.
My opinion ain't shit.