Poll Is Diddy A Top 5 Beatmaker?

[Goldie]

 

[Chi-Town B]

He might be, let me think on it for a minute

 

[Goldie]

Puff has produced more classics than any producer we've ranked so far outside of Pharrell.

 

[Chi-Town B]

I'm putting him top 5. After the east/west shit was over Puff was putting out nothing but bangers for the last 20+ years from hip hop to r&b

 

[Goldie]

Not to mention he changed the sound hip hop AND RnB.

 

[Chi-Town B]

Made Mary J Blige's career along with Biggie and everyone from Bad Boy. Gave Mariah some hits. It was a point where damn near every hit either came from him or Timbaland. People frown because of all the samples he used but that was really the best time in music to me

 

[Achewon87]

If it was The Hitmen I would have voted yes...

Puff rarely if ever produced anything by himself...

 

[🌊City]

If it was The Hitmen I would have voted yes...

Puff rarely if ever produced anything by himself...

This my thought

 

[Goldie]

Not that bullshit again...

I aint in the mood to teach about the difference of beatmaker and producer today, yall got it.

 

[genocide_cutter]

Rofl

 

[Shaquille Sunflower]

Close but no

 

[🌊City]

Not that bullshit again...

I aint in the mood to teach about the difference of beatmaker and producer today, yall got it.

Look there's a reason why there's a Mo Town sound and not a Berry Gordy sound

Puff no doubt top 5 Executive Producers, that ain't to be discredited, but when you say producer 9/10 you talking about someone who makes a beat or has a hand in making beats

Two different jobs and functions

 

[AP4.0]

I hate to agree with this nigga but he right

 

[Goldie]

Look there's a reason why there's a Mo Town sound and not a Berry Gordy sound

Puff no doubt top 5 Executive Producers, that ain't to be discredited, but when you say producer 9/10 you talking about someone who makes a beat or has a hand in making beats

Two different jobs and functions

You don't think Diddy had a hand in beat making? Wtf u think he was doing, eating burgers while everything was being created?

The nigga changed the sound of multiple genres.

 

[🌊City]

You don't think Diddy had a hand in beat making? Wtf u think he was doing, eating burgers while everything was being created?

The nigga changed the sound of multiple genres.

No doubt he has hand in beatmaking but Diddy has 2 things going against him

1) no solo producing work
2) the nigga known for taking credit for shit he has nothing to do with.

You asking for producers and listing his executive qualities lol

 

[Mooney]

Not that bullshit again...

I aint in the mood to teach about the difference of beatmaker and producer today, yall got it.

Let me find out you losing ya tenacity!!!

Get at 'em Goldie
Yo, if niggas wanna act we can act
You niggas wanna scrap, we could scrap
You niggas got gatts, we got gatts
You niggas wanna style, we style
If you get foul, we get foul
You get wild, we get wild

 

[AZTG]

I get the difference between producer and beat maker but in hip hop the lines are blurred. To be a top 5 hip hop producer you gotta be both.

 

[Goldie]

Good chatting with you guys

 

[Chi-Town B]

Good chatting with you guys

Just for the hell of it do Pimp C

 

[Shaquille Sunflower]

Just for the hell of it do Pimp C

Lol this seems like bait