We talking overall? I'd say black MJ based on music, but he became the GOAT performer during his ligther shades. The dancing, live performances, videos,etc.
U could be right, but I'd argue that.
Better video than
Better performance than:
I gotta go with caucasian mj for these two songs alone:
MJ wanted to be in Guns N Roses so bad in the late 80's lmaothis nigga was all the way out there tho.....