True or False: Did Eminem Murder Jay Z On His Own Shhh?

[5th Letter]

This has been the general consensus for years especially after Ether. What say y’all?

 

[Goldie]

I wouldn't say he murdered him, but he did outshine him.

 

[5th Letter]

Absolutely not.

 

[Goldie]

why the hell u ask then lol

 

[Matike85]

True...Nas the God Son just stated and made it factual since 2001..

 

[5th Letter]

why the hell u ask then lol

Seeing what y’all think.

 

[Goldie]

oh i thought u were responding to me lol

 

[Matike85]

oh i thought u were responding to me lol

@5th Letter ...For simple fact you choose Ether to response to @Goldie ...Nas Won & Jay-Z took 2 L's in the Fall 2001 to Nas & Eminem...

 

[L3NU]

How much does it irk you when someone votes for eminem lol

 

[CeLLar-DooR]

Em had the better verses but I definitely wouldn't call it a murder

 

[313 Wayz]

Jay did his thing on it though but Em's technique on this was incredible..........this video breaks it down

 

[OGDirtyD]

Random: its wild the increase in Em hate these days just getting bigger as time goes.

But anyway Jay verses were cool but Em broke that that shit down and delivered better. I remember doing the test track pull up around that time playing it for people who aint heard it to ask who was better to them, i never came across somebody who said Jay.

 

[OGDirtyD]

Murdering is a little tough, easier question is did Em outshine Jay and I think we all would agree there.

 

[Infamous114]

Random: its wild the increase in Em hate these days just getting bigger as time goes.

But anyway Jay verses were cool but Em broke that that shit down and delivered better. I remember doing the test track pull up around that time playing it for people who aint heard it to ask who was better to them, i never came across somebody who said Jay.

For some, his music aged terribly. For others, it's hard to overlook the racist tapes.

 

[Lou Cypher]

I believe he did. They were on different shit with their raps though. 2 different messages. Just up to your preference of what speaks to you more.

 

[Dwayne]

Nope.

Not even close

 

[Dwayne]

I felt what Jay was talking about "

It resonated with me more than what Em was talking about

 

[MECCA1000]

It wouldn't even be up for debate 15 some odd years later if remotely true.
Oh course Emily flow was on point, it was his song 1st before Jay jumped on it. But shined through with his lyrical content.

East coast biased

 

[Sage Wonder]

Random: its wild the increase in Em hate these days just getting bigger as time goes.

But anyway Jay verses were cool but Em broke that that shit down and delivered better. I remember doing the test track pull up around that time playing it for people who aint heard it to ask who was better to them, i never came across somebody who said Jay.

I don't think anybody is arguing Jay did better, but his verses were pretty incredible too.

 

[Duwop]

Naw, they were spitting at the same level

I think hearing em hold his own so well with Jay added more shock value than anything