Poll (Qtr Finals) Goat TV Show Tournament: Dexter vs Black Mirror

[Goldie]

Pick one

 

[DMorgan]

I didn't like Dexter. Saw a few episodes. I also didn't watch it from the the first episode of the first season. So that could be why I didn't like it.

 

[Bow to Royalty]

Black Mirror is about to turn into that team that makes a deep run and messes up all the good matchups you wanted to see.

 

[Bow to Royalty]

Basically off 2 seasons worth of episodes too?! Fuck it, I'll join the mayhem... changing my vote to Black Mirror.

@AP21 you gave the winning vote last round and said "hmmm...this is kinda tough for me as both shows were must watch at their peaks but both shows also have huge dives as the season went on". Bruh, it only has 22 episodes! Haha. If it already took a huge dive that fast, why vote for it? Don't try to sound extra analytical, just say "I didn't like the other show."

 

[AP3.0]

Basically off 2 seasons worth of episodes too?! Fuck it, I'll join the mayhem... changing my vote to Black Mirror.

@AP21 you gave the winning vote last round and said "hmmm...this is kinda tough for me as both shows were must watch at their peaks but both shows also have huge dives as the season went on". Bruh, it only has 22 episodes! Haha. If it already took a huge dive that fast, why vote for it? Don't try to sound extra analytical, just say "I didn't like the other show."

Quality over quantity every single time

I watched both shows extensively and still feel the way I felt when I made my vote

 

[Chi-Town B]

Ain't black mirror some twilight zone type shit

 

[Bow to Royalty]

Quality over quantity every single time

I watched both shows extensively and still feel the way I felt when I made my vote

A respectable stance, and I get that logic. But you said it took a huge dive, so that's a criticism of the show's quality. If you said it was 22 episodes of perfection, I'd get your point.

 

[Bow to Royalty]

Ain't black mirror some twilight zone type shit

Yes.

 

[Duwop]

dexter had a spark when he first started...

some shit just ain't meant to be popular...

i read the books and watched the show.... the books were better, but even they fell off very quickly.. the show fell off quicker


black mirror continues to be great with each season and movie

 

[Inori]

Black Mirror gets my vote on this one.. Dexter was great in the beginning but like I said in the other thread that last season or two was terrible.. and that ending...smh

 

[Chi-Town B]

View attachment 185084

Black Mirror gets my vote on this one.. Dexter was great in the beginning but like I said in the other thread that last season or two was terrible.. and that ending...smh

They fucked up killing Doakes off

 

[Bow to Royalty]

They fucked up killing Doakes off

When Rita got killed though...Shit was a 1 woman red wedding

 

[Norrin_Radd]

dexter had a spark when he first started...

some shit just ain't meant to be popular...

i read the books and watched the show.... the books were better, but even they fell off very quickly.. the show fell off quicker


black mirror continues to be great with each season and movie

Really?

 

[Revolver Ocelot]

They fucked up killing Doakes off

Nah, they killed him off at the right time.

No need to string it out over a another season or 2, just for him to not catch Dexter or end up dead anyway.