Poll Is Timbaland A Top 5 Beatmaker?

[Goldie]

 

[Mooney]

That boy got a distinctive sound!

 

[Silverfoxx]

Influenced me the most as a producer

 

[CeLLar-DooR]

The other guys in my top 5 have produced classic rap albums and Tim's CV just doesn't stack up.

He could go beat for beat with any of them tho'

 

[KINGEC]

He ain't in my personal but he def is top 5.

Shouldn't see nobody saying he aint.

 

[AP3.0]

Why has the question changed from producer to beat maker?

Because of Puff?

 

[NAWLEDGE_GOD]

Objectively Yes

Personally No

His Is Best Shit Was With Aaliyah And Ginuwine IMO

 

[aka_og]

Top 5 in hip hop - id say no,
Top 5 in pop/rnb - yes
Top 10 in hp hop - ok

 

[Maywood]

Man Get this Video Game Beat ass Nigga outta Here

 

[Chicity]

His catalog vast as fuck

I agree with OG *and I hope most others* that his R&B records far superior to his Rap records but overall as a producer/beat maker he a beast

I wouldnt argue him being in the top 5