Poll Goat NFL Quarterbacks: Pick 5

[Goldie]

Pick 5

(1980s-now)

 

[O.G.]

Hard to debate QB's bcuz of TEAM success & schemes are always brought up and cloud the debate.

 

[mike030270]

Hard to debate QB's bcuz of TEAM success & schemes are always brought up and cloud the debate.

More like hard to debate QBs from different eras where rules were drastically different

 

[O.G.]

More like hard to debate QBs from different eras where rules were drastically different

That too.

 

[O.G.]

Just slanging the rock tho.

Marino
Elway
Mahomes
Manning
Rogers

 

[Revolver Ocelot]

Brady
Elway
Pat
Payton
Montana

 

[already home_17]

brady
montana
mahomes
manning
favre

 

[RandomNegro]

Brady
Montana
Mahomes
Peyton
Elway

 

[BDBOULIBALY]

I just picked my favorites

Pat
Rodgers
Elway
Brees
Tom

 

[southsil4lil]

Imagine not voting for Patrick Mahomes

 

[FIRE BOBBY SLOWIK]

Marino needs more votes

 

[Ibex]

1. Michael Vick
2. Peyton Manning
3. Tom Brady
4. Patrick Mahomes
5. Joe Montana

 

[Goldie]

1. Michael Vick

I was tempted to add Vick and Lamar Jackson.


Vick would be on the convo if it wasn't for the dog shit.

 

[Reed MJ]

The disrespect for Marino is real

 

[Goldie]

The disrespect for Marino is real

Everybody else got rings.


Still in my top 5 tho.

 

[Suckio Andretti]

Pick your favorite whites!

 

[Breezy_Kilroy]

I meant Brady not John Elway but it is what it is. He got enough votes

 

[Agent_Ro]

Michael Vick is NOT a GOAT QB

Lmao

 

[onetoughmiracle]

Brady
Elway
Montana
Young
Manning