Classic or Nah: Vol 1: Kanye - Graduation

[Goldie]

Once we get our first album voted classic, I'll create the Vault.

15 classic votes and 0 nah votes is an automatic entry to the vault.


After yesterday's Kanye thread it's only right we start with this album for Vol 1.

​

 

[AP3.0]

i dont get the hate for Graduation

i thought it had MAD replay value

dope beats, bars, content. The features were good, not great, but they fit the songs they were one

im good on this being a classic

 

[Goldie]

@Achewon87 @BDBIID explain your votes

 

[BDBOULIBALY]

Near classic for me. Just not quite

 

[Achewon87]

Too many skips for me...

 

[BDP™️]

i dont get the hate for Graduation

i thought it had MAD replay value

dope beats, bars, content. The features were good, not great, but they fit the songs they were one

im good on this being a classic

Graduation has the most replay value out of all of Ye’s albums. Whenever I want to listen to Kanye...Graduation is usually the first album I put on

And yes its a classic...

Only Kanye albums that are not classics are Yeezus and TLOP

 

[Goldie]

Near classic for me. Just not quite

Too many skips for me...

What are the skippable tracks?

 

[Achewon87]

4, 7, 8, 12, 13....

 

[Goldie]

U skip this?




:huh:

 

[AP3.0]

Graduation has the most replay value out of all of Ye’s albums. Whenever I want to listen to Kanye...Graduation is usually the first album I put on

And yes its a classic...

Only Kanye albums that are not classics are Yeezus and TLOP

more replay than CD?

that album is damn near flawless...nah...it is flawless

it is permanently in my top 3 of ALL time

 

[AP3.0]

U skip this?




:huh:

man both versions of homecoming were dope af

i just wish Ye would've kept Legend on the hook with this beat even tho the og one was fire too

 

[Nah Son]

I love this album but I wouldn't call it a classic. 4/5 album for me

Kanye got three classics imo. CD, LR and MBDTW

 

[FakeOhMars]

Really good album. Im on the fence about it's classic status.

Someone convince me one way or the other

 

[Nah Son]

Really good album. Im on the fence about it's classic status.

Someone convince me one way or the other

Well not tryin to hate on the album but it does arguably feature the WOAT Kanye song lol

 

[FakeOhMars]

Out of 13, 3 are pretty shitty

 

[ThaEruditious]

Yes for me

 

[ThaEruditious]

And before it's mentioned, I love D&HGs even though the topic is trash

 

[ChiGetTheMoney]

Stadium status!

Every song grand af. Nigga snapped on every track

Smh at this being debatable

My big brother, was Bigs brother
Uses to be Dame and Biggs brother

Toomp killed that shit

 

[FakeOhMars]

Stadium status!

Every song grand af. Nigga snapped on every track

Smh at this being debatable

My big brother, was Bigs brother
Uses to be Dame and Biggs brother

Toomp killed that shit

But what about drunk and hot girls (rape song)
&
Barry Bonds

 

[Goldie]

In Ye's defense, he spazzed on Barry Bonds, Wayne was the one who half assed on the track