2X Super Bowl Champion
4X Pro Bowl
57,023 Yards
60% Completion
366 TD’s
HOF or FOH: Eli Manning
- Thread starter 5th Letter
- Start date
2X Super Bowl Champion
4X Pro Bowl
57,023 Yards
60% Completion
366 TD’s
He's one
Disanthrope
Inconvenient truth + Necessary evil
mryounggun
OG
The fact of the matter is that over his entire career, Eli Manning was an AVERAGE quarterback.
2 Super Bowls combined with him putting up good/decent numbers will get him in. The question is will he get in first ballot?
Disanthrope
Inconvenient truth + Necessary evil
No way, make him wait 2 or 3 ballots
Lord Nemesis
I’ve had to zip up my nigga suit once in a while
Personally don't think he is but he's definitely getting in
Elzo69Renaissance
Didnt you hear about the last nigga who swung @ me
First ballot Hall of famer
wadupdoe!313
OG
Eli Manning is not in my HOF but he will get in and he should not be a first ballot.
The fact that media and fans are debating his HOF worthiness should let us know that he is not a first ballot HOF.
If you play this game a long time you're gonna accumulate stats
The fact that media and fans are debating his HOF worthiness should let us know that he is not a first ballot HOF.
If you play this game a long time you're gonna accumulate stats
Elzo69Renaissance
Didnt you hear about the last nigga who swung @ me
2 super bowl my G
wadupdoe!313
OG
Y'all dont remember but the year before the giants won in 2006 the question was is Eli a bust. Giants and media were wondering if they should move on from Eli.
Even in the regular season in 07 Eli stunk it up bad and there was one game towards the end of the year when he played terrible. It was the Vikings, he threw 4 interceptions and 3 were returned for TDs. Then they went on the miraculous run in the playoffs and the defense was dominant. Eli just didn't make turnovers and made some nice throws when it mattered.
From 2008 to 2011 when the Giants won the superbowl in 2011 Eli still wasn't dominant.
Here are his stats:
TD- 108
Int- 65
Completion pctg- 61%
Fumbles- 38
Fumbles lost- 19
He was average during that 4 year stretch and had another amazing superbowl run
Even in the regular season in 07 Eli stunk it up bad and there was one game towards the end of the year when he played terrible. It was the Vikings, he threw 4 interceptions and 3 were returned for TDs. Then they went on the miraculous run in the playoffs and the defense was dominant. Eli just didn't make turnovers and made some nice throws when it mattered.
From 2008 to 2011 when the Giants won the superbowl in 2011 Eli still wasn't dominant.
Here are his stats:
TD- 108
Int- 65
Completion pctg- 61%
Fumbles- 38
Fumbles lost- 19
He was average during that 4 year stretch and had another amazing superbowl run
Elzo69Renaissance
Didnt you hear about the last nigga who swung @ me
2 Super Bowls dog
Disanthrope
Inconvenient truth + Necessary evil
Nah b, that would undermine the elite first ballot players. 1st ballot is HOF of the HOF
BDBIID
| we past kneeling | Russ trick y’all |
Elzo69Renaissance
Didnt you hear about the last nigga who swung @ me
That’s different .....number 1 pick ...put up numbers .....won 2 of them shits...that simple...one hell of a career
BDBIID
| we past kneeling | Russ trick y’all |
Plunkett was a number 1 pick as well put up solid numbers for his era .
Manning winning percentage is.500 regular season .667 postseason 8-4 record
Plunkett winning percentage .500, .800 postseason 8-2 record
All Eli has is numbers (different era) and last name. Sucks Jim is not Joe Montana’s brother